Hey you, through October 31, you can subscribe to The Happenstance for $2/month!
Every single night, my sons and I watch an episode or two of a sitcom before bed.
The lights are off, except for the glow of the television. We’re not facing each other. We’re just there, together, laughing at something Ray Barone or Michael Scott said, and somewhere between the jokes and the end credits, the most extraordinary conversations happen.
They ask me questions about my childhood. I tell them stories about the people I knew, the things I did, and who I was before I became their mother. They tell me things that have been occupying their minds, questions they’ve been sitting with, something that happened at school, or something from three years ago that has suddenly become interesting again.
Sometimes the conversations are hilarious. Sometimes they’re surprisingly profound. Sometimes I learn something about one of my children that I don’t think I would have discovered any other way.
And they’re learning about me, too.
Not just as their mother, but as a person who existed before them. Someone who had a childhood, friendships, heartbreaks, adventures, and a life that was already well underway by the time they arrived.

These are some of my favorite moments of motherhood. I wouldn’t trade them for anything.
But here’s something I’ve been thinking about lately: These moments only exist because I’m divorced.
I don’t think I would have had them if I were still married.
And a recent New York Times article about a mother using artificial intelligence to describe what made her daughter special has made me think about why.
In the article, Marissa Mayer, the former CEO of Yahoo and a longtime Google executive, described being asked by her daughter’s teacher to provide three things that made her daughter special.
Mayer turned to an AI assistant developed by her company, Dazzle, for help. The technology suggested that her daughter was empathetic, creative, and an animal lover. Mayer reportedly thought the answer was perfect.
The internet, predictably, had quite a lot to say about this.
People were horrified by the idea that a mother would need artificial intelligence to describe her own child. How could someone spend years raising a daughter and need a computer to identify three things that made her extraordinary?
And of course I understand the reaction, but I found myself thinking about something else entirely.
What if one of the reasons mothers struggle to find the time and emotional space to truly know their children has very little to do with the demands of motherhood itself, and everything to do with the demands of managing their husbands?
What if we’ve become so accustomed to women carrying the practical and emotional responsibilities of an entire household that we’ve failed to consider what that arrangement takes away from their relationships with their children?
Because when a woman is spending her days anticipating another adult’s needs, managing his moods, compensating for his refusal to participate, and calculating the consequences of disappointing him, what is left of her for the children?
Not just her time. Her curiosity. Her patience. Her playfulness. Her ability to sit on the floor and become completely absorbed in a ridiculous game. Her capacity to listen to a story that takes twenty minutes to tell and doesn’t really have a point.
The parts of motherhood that allow her to discover who her children are, rather than simply keep them alive and cared for.
And I wonder how many mothers are grieving the loss of that intimacy without even realizing what they’re grieving, because they’ve been so consumed with managing their husbands that they haven’t had the opportunity to fully experience their children’s childhoods.
I don’t know Marissa Mayer’s marriage. I don’t know how parenting responsibilities are divided in her household, or what kind of relationship she has with her daughter.
But I do know what it’s like to be a mother whose attention is constantly being pulled away from her children by the needs and expectations of their father.
Because that was my marriage.
And I think we need to talk about what that costs our children.
Before my divorce, bedtime was something to get through.
As much as my children needed a consistent bedtime routine, it was difficult to create one when there was another adult in the house who didn’t particularly want to participate in that routine.
Their bedroom backed up to our living room, and often, while I was trying to read them a story or sing them lullabies, the sound of YouTube videos would come through the wall.
I would be sitting there, trying to create this lovely, peaceful transition from the day into sleep, and there would be another soundtrack playing in the background.
And I was left with a choice.
I could ask my husband to turn down the volume, knowing that the request might be met with resentment, being iced out, and declarations that he simply wouldn’t watch television in the living room anymore, that he would just have to be miserable.
Or I could say nothing and continue trying to put my children to sleep with the sound of YouTube videos coming through the wall.
Neither option allowed me to focus completely on my children.
One meant managing my husband’s reaction. The other meant managing the disruption to my children’s bedtime.
And either way, I was the one responsible for making bedtime work.
I think about that now, because what an extraordinary amount of emotional energy was being spent on something as simple as singing my children to sleep.
I wasn’t just thinking about the story I was reading or the song I was singing. I was calculating whether I should say something, what would happen if I did, how the rest of the evening might unfold, and whether I had the emotional bandwidth to deal with another conflict.
And all the while, I was rushing. I had client work waiting for me. At the time, I was running a marketing agency, and my clients depended on me to finish the work I’d promised them. But I couldn’t get everything done during the day because I was also the primary parent. I was cooking the meals, doing the laundry, cleaning the house, caring for the children, and managing all the ordinary responsibilities that make a household function.
So the work I couldn’t finish during the day became the work I had to finish at night. And bedtime became the thing standing between me and all of those responsibilities. I wasn’t sitting beside my children thinking about what they might want to tell me. I was thinking about how much work I had left to do and whether I could get them to sleep quickly enough to finish it.
But I don’t even think time was the biggest problem.
I think the bigger problem was that my nervous system was on such high alert that I couldn’t really settle into the moments I was having with my children.
I was constantly scanning the environment. What was going to happen next? What needed to be done? Where was I supposed to be? Who was going to be upset? What had I forgotten? What responsibility was waiting for me? What could I do now to prevent something from becoming a problem later?
Even when I was sitting perfectly still beside my children, my mind was running through an endless inventory of things that needed my attention.
And I think that’s something we don’t talk about enough when we discuss the mental load.
It’s not simply that you’re doing too many things. It’s that your mind never gets permission to stop preparing for the next thing.
You can be physically present with your children while your entire nervous system is occupied with managing another person.
When you’re constantly being pulled in a hundred directions, when there is always another demand waiting for you and another person’s reaction to anticipate, the ordinary needs of your children can begin to feel like one more thing you have to rush through. Not because you don’t want to be there.
Because you don’t know how to stop.
There’s something I wish people understood about the advice we give overwhelmed mothers.
We tell them that the dishes can wait. That the laundry can wait. That the vacuuming can wait. We tell them to sit on the floor and play with their children, to stop worrying about the mess, to enjoy these years because they’ll be over before they know it.
And in theory, that’s lovely advice.
But I think it reveals a complete misunderstanding of what life is like in many heterosexual marriages where household labor is unequal and one partner is also expected to manage the other’s emotional reactions.
Because yes, the dishes can wait.
But the consequences of leaving them might not.
Imagine a mother sitting at the kitchen table with her children, helping them make an art project.
There are paints spread across the table. Paper on the floor. A pile of dishes in the sink. The laundry hasn’t been folded.
And she’s having a wonderful time.
She’s laughing with her children. She’s discovering the extraordinary little things their minds come up with. She’s watching them create something. She’s enjoying being their mother.
But there’s another adult in the house. An adult who isn’t going to do the dishes himself, but is perfectly willing to express his displeasure that they haven’t been done. An adult who might walk through the kitchen and comment on the mess.
What did you do all day? Why is the house such a disaster? How come nothing ever gets finished around here?
Or perhaps he doesn’t say anything at all.
Perhaps he simply sulks. Perhaps his mood changes. Perhaps he makes it clear, through his silence or his irritation, that he is unhappy with the state of the household and that somebody ought to do something about it.
And suddenly, that beautiful little afternoon at the kitchen table isn’t so beautiful anymore.
The mother is distracted. She’s irritated. She’s trying to enjoy her children while simultaneously managing the emotional consequences of not having done the dishes.
She might begin cleaning up before the children are finished. She might become short with them when they spill something. She might rush the project because she’s conscious of the mess accumulating around them. She might even find herself resenting the very activity she wanted so badly to share with them.
Not because the children have done anything wrong.
Because the pleasure of being with them has become entangled with the anticipated displeasure of another adult.
And here’s what I think is so profoundly unfair.
She had two choices.
She could do the dishes, the laundry, and the vacuuming, and lose the time she wanted to spend with her children.
Or she could leave those things undone, spend time with her children, and risk being criticized, ridiculed, or emotionally punished for doing so.
Either way, the mother pays.
In one version, she loses the time. In the other, she loses the ability to enjoy the time. And in both versions, her children lose something, too.
This is why I struggle with the way we talk about mothers needing to prioritize what’s important. Because the implication is that the solution is simply a matter of making better choices. Choose the children over the dishes. Choose connection over productivity. Choose memories over a clean house.
But what if those choices aren’t actually available to her without consequences? What if choosing to spend an afternoon with her children means spending the evening managing a husband’s resentment? What if leaving the laundry unfolded means criticism about her competence? What if the very act of investing her attention in her children creates tension because another adult resents not being the person receiving that attention?
Then we’re not talking about a woman who needs better priorities. We’re talking about a woman whose priorities are being controlled by the consequences attached to her choices. And that changes the conversation entirely.
I think we misunderstand the urgency of managing another adult.
When we talk about weaponized incompetence, we usually describe it as a division-of-labor problem.
The husband who doesn’t know how to operate the washing machine. The father who can’t remember which pediatrician his children see. The adult man who needs his wife to explain how to pack a lunch, schedule a dentist’s appointment, or figure out what needs to be purchased at the grocery store.
And yes, those things do create more work.
But weaponized incompetence becomes something even more consuming when it comes with criticism, resentment, or emotional punishment.
Because now you’re not simply responsible for completing the work another adult refuses to do. You’re responsible for managing his reaction if you decide not to do it. And sometimes the possibility of that reaction is more exhausting than the work itself.
Consider something as ordinary as a shirt.
If the shirt he wants to wear isn’t clean, he’s going to be frustrated.
If he’s frustrated, he might not feel confident going to work.
If he doesn’t feel confident going to work, perhaps his performance will suffer.
If his performance suffers, what if something goes wrong? What if his job is affected? What if his mood follows him home and becomes everybody else’s problem?
And so a woman who is ostensibly just doing laundry can find herself feeling responsible for preventing an entire imagined chain of consequences.
The stakes of every ordinary household task become disproportionately enormous. It’s no longer simply about whether the laundry gets done. It’s about what might happen if it doesn’t.
And this is how managing another adult becomes so much more consuming than completing tasks. You’re managing possibilities. You’re preparing for reactions. You’re trying to prevent things that haven’t happened yet.
Suddenly, you’re making decisions based not on whose needs are most important, but on whose unmet needs are going to create the greatest disruption.
You’re running triage between your children and their father. And the person whose reaction feels most consequential can end up receiving the most immediate attention.
Not because you love that person more. Not because your children matter less. But because you’re trying to keep the entire household from becoming emotionally unmanageable.
Perhaps many mothers are so accustomed to preventing the next conflict that they no longer recognize how much of their daily life is devoted to anticipation.
Because there’s only so much attention a human being can give, only so much emotional energy available.
And when so much of yours is occupied with monitoring another adult’s mood and preventing his dissatisfaction, there is less available for the unhurried curiosity that intimacy requires.
Weaponized incompetence doesn’t just steal a woman’s time. It can steal her children’s access to her attention, her playfulness, her curiosity, and the version of herself she might have been if she weren’t constantly bracing for what came next.
And I think that’s a loss we haven’t begun to calculate.
Think about some of the ordinary moments you remember from your own childhood.
Sitting in the car with your parents. Waiting at the breakfast table. Getting ready for school. Riding somewhere with nothing in particular to talk about.
Not every family was loving or attentive, and I’m not suggesting that life before smartphones was some golden age of parenting.
But there was something about the ordinary, unscheduled moments of being together that made room for people to know one another. You learned about your parents in fragments. A story about something they did as a child. An opinion about a song on the radio. A joke you didn’t understand until you were older. Something they said while making breakfast that stayed with you for decades.
And your parents learned about you in the same way. Through the ordinary accumulation of small observations. What made you laugh. What made you nervous. How your sense of humor was developing. The interests you were beginning to discover that had nothing to do with the person they’d imagined you would become.
These moments are how families develop intimacy.
Not simply by living in the same house, but by having enough room in their lives to become acquainted with one another. And now, so much of that room has been occupied.
We like to blame phones.
We see a mother looking at her screen while her children are playing and wonder why she isn’t paying attention. But what is she actually doing on that phone?
She’s answering the teacher’s email. She’s arranging a doctor’s appointment. She’s checking whether the prescription is ready. She’s making the grocery list. She’s ordering new shoes. She’s coordinating a birthday party. She’s answering a work call. She’s making sure everyone is where they need to be tomorrow.
Her phone has become the administrative headquarters of an entire family.
And she carries it everywhere because she’s responsible for making sure that family keeps functioning. Sometimes, there is another adult sitting right beside her. An adult who benefits from all that invisible labor without necessarily participating in it.
And I think there’s something cruel about the way we then criticize mothers for being distracted.
We build households that require them to be constantly available to everyone, and then criticize them for not being fully present with anyone.
We expect them to carry the responsibilities of multiple adults and then ask why they don’t seem to be enjoying motherhood enough. We tell them to put down their phones without asking why all the work of their families lives inside those phones.
And we rarely ask what might happen if another adult simply took responsibility for an equal share of the work.
Not helped. Not waited for instructions. Not completed the occasional task after being reminded thirty times. But genuinely assumed responsibility for the children and the household, including the planning, anticipating, remembering, and emotional labor that makes family life possible.
I wonder how many mothers are grieving something they don’t yet have a name for.
Because I don’t think you necessarily recognize this kind of loss while you’re living inside it. You know you’re exhausted. You know there’s always more to do. You know you sometimes feel impatient with your children, even though you love them more than anything. You wish you had more time to play with them, or listen to them, or simply enjoy them.
But you might not realize that you’re grieving.
You’re too busy managing the life you’re living to think about the life you’re missing.
And even if you do recognize the loss, what are you supposed to do with it?
You can’t make another adult participate willingly. You can’t simply stop doing the things your children depend on you to do. And you can’t decide to stop being vigilant when the consequences of letting your guard down are part of what makes you vigilant in the first place.
So you keep going.
You tell yourself things will be easier when the children are older. When work slows down. When life is less stressful. You imagine that somewhere on the other side of all the responsibilities, there will be room for the motherhood you wanted. And meanwhile, your children keep growing. They become more independent, as they’re supposed to.
And perhaps one day you look back and realize that the time you were waiting for never arrived. Not because you didn’t understand what was important, but because managing another adult consumed so much of you that you couldn’t fully participate in the childhood happening right in front of you.
You cannot ask a woman to be constantly responsible for everyone’s needs and then wonder why she doesn’t have the emotional space to delight in anyone’s existence.
And that includes her own.
I think about the mother I was when my sons were little.
I think about how desperately I wanted to give my children the childhood I imagined for them, and how much energy I was spending managing responsibilities and reactions that had very little to do with them.
And I wonder what I might have noticed if I hadn’t been so tense.
I did have beautiful moments with them. I have wonderful memories of those years, and I never want to erase them. But I also know there were so many moments when I wasn’t the mother I wanted to be. Not because I wasn’t trying hard enough. Because I was trying so hard at everything else.
There is a grief in recognizing that. And it’s a grief that can’t be resolved by simply reminding yourself that you did the best you could. Because even when you understand why something happened, you can still wish it had been different.
My children will never be those ages again. I will never get to sit on the floor with those particular versions of my sons.
I can’t go back and give myself the calm I didn’t have. I can’t go back and recover the energy I spent anticipating someone else’s reactions. And I can’t recover the pieces of their childhood that passed while I was trying to keep everything functioning.
But I can recognize what I have now.
And perhaps that’s one of the most profound things divorce gave me.
Not simply the removal of another adult’s responsibilities, but the removal of the constant anticipation of another adult’s reaction.
I don’t think I fully understood how much of myself had been occupied by that vigilance until I finally had enough room to notice its absence.
Now I have the freedom to let my children be children, and to be there with them while they do it. The freedom to sit with a question instead of rushing toward an answer. The freedom to know them as people, and to let them know me.
And the emotional energy to actually enjoy those experiences.
Because childhood is happening whether we have the capacity to notice it or not. And their mothers deserve to be there for it. Not simply physically present.
Not simply doing the work of keeping everyone alive and cared for. But emotionally available enough to experience the extraordinary privilege of getting to know the people they’ve brought into the world.
Sometimes I wish I could go back to that mother sitting in the dark, trying to sing over the noise coming through the wall.
I’d like to tell her that one day, bedtime won’t feel like another thing she has to get through.
One day, she’ll be able to lie beside her children without her mind racing toward everything that needs to happen next. One day, she’ll hear them laughing and won’t have to worry about anybody else’s reaction.
She’ll laugh out loud with them.
And for once, there won’t be anything more urgent than that.
A little Happenstance reminder: Most of what I write here is free. A few essays are paid, mostly because my children know how to use Google and I would like to preserve a tiny shred of dignity. Every paid subscription helps fund someone else’s fresh start through Fresh Starts Registry and our divorce registries. And through October 31, you can lock in paid Happenstance for $2/month instead of $5/month for as long as you stay subscribed. ❤️


Whew! Wow. This one hits so hard.
I didn't always want to have children. I used to think, What if I don't like being a mother? What if I don't like them? I can't give them back. Turns out, I adore my children, and I'm glad I'm a mother. It's the ex I needed to give back.
Your essay triggered so many memories of what was painful and difficult. Getting out of the house in the morning and getting the kids to school always carried the possibility of some explosion or other from him. More than once, he got so angry that he slammed his hand on the kitchen table in front of one of the kids and stormed out of the house, leaving me with 20 minutes to gather my crying child together, get everything done with all three kids (teeth brushed, backpacks packed, etc.), out the door, in the car and off to school.
When I tried to talk to him about that behavior later, instead of acknowledging how wrong it was and promising to never do it again, he got mad that I said I was so tired of "cleaning up after him" after he did something to hurt the kids. THAT's what became the problem. My words. Not his abusive behavior. A few more of those incidents and I realized I needed to get my kids away from that. And I did.
Even after I left, though, he still expected me to manage his feelings. Why don't the kids call or text me? Why don't I hear from them? Why don't they want to talk to me? (Meaning, what are YOU doing to keep them away from me?)
I was learning how to "gray rock," so I didn't text-scream at him what was in my head: that it was such a relief for ALL of us to get away from him, and we were all trying to work through that (like finding therapists, which he refused to support when he controlled everything) while trying to get through everyday life. Sometimes there's no time. And sometimes we just don't want to hit the hornet's nest anymore.
I read this, now I feel like going somewhere and having a good cry. Sounds so much like my life.